Feedback Report Summary
Navigate through extractive report cases
Cases Received and Served
Case Number
Issue Concern
Location
Complainant
Date Filed
Status
:
:
:
:
:
:
Nickel mining operations of Altai Philippines Mining Corporation (APMC)
Sibuyan Island, Romblon
Mayor Trina Alejandra Q. Firmalo-Fabic of the Municipality of Odiongan
January 2023
The Supreme Court (SC) has issued a writ of kalikasan against APMC in relation to a petition seeking to protect Sibuyan Island from environmental destruction due to mining activities.
Case Number
Issue Concern
Location
Complainant
Date Filed
Status
:
:
:
:
:
:
Ipilan Nickel Corporation (INC) Mining Issue
Maasin, Brooke’s Point, Palawan
Ms. Aniceta Baltar (PH-EITI MSG-CSO member representative), pastoral groups , & community of Ipilan
August 2023
The Supreme Court (SC) has issued a writ of kalikasan against INC, responding to petitions from indigenous cultural communities in Brooke’s Point. The petitioners argued that the mining operations encroached upon the Mt. Mantalingahan Protected Landscape, part of the National Integrated Protected Areas System, rendering the mining activities illegal.
Case Number
Issue Concern
Location
Complainant
Date Filed
Status
:
:
:
:
:
:
Coal Mining Activities in Lake Sebu, South Cotabato
Brgy Ned, Lake Sebu, South Cotabato
Philippine Misereor Partnership, Inc.;
Fr. Jerome Nian, Diocese of Marbel;
Jay Martin Ablola, Project Officer for PMPI;
Atty. Josiah Quising, Campaign Lawyer for Rights of Nature, PMPI
August 2023
During the 3rd Governance of the Committee (GOC) meeting on May 31, 2023, a complaint regarding coal mining activities was raised. The PH-EITI Secretariat shared the discussion that took place during the meeting with PMPI. In this meeting, the Department of Energy (DOE) provided a brief description of the San Miguel mining projects in Lake Sebu, South Cotabato, stating that they had recently commenced. It was revealed that the company had waited for endorsement from the Sangguniang Panlalawigan for the past 10 years before being able to operate fully. Reports on geohazards in the area had been submitted by the Mines and Geosciences Bureau (MGB) prior to the commencement of mining operations. The Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) had issued an Environmental Compliance Certificate (ECC) to the company. Additionally, the company and DOE had a discussion with Reverend Cerilio Casicas of the Diocese of Marbel on April 12, 2023, regarding the coal mining activities.
The GOC agreed to wait for a direct complaint letter from PMPI, which would then be endorsed to the DOE. Once the official complaint letter is received, the DOE will provide the requested documents to PMPI.
Case Number
Issue Concern
Location
Complainant
Date Filed
Status
:
:
:
:
:
:
Delayed release of royalty shares from SR Metals Inc.
Agusan del Norte
IP communities in Agusan del Norte:
MAPASO IP Community, Brgy. La Paz, Santiago;
Coro IP Community, Brgy. Colorado, Jabonga;
Mamanwa-Manobo of Tubay, Agusan del Norte
September 2023
The PH-EITI Secretariat has reviewed the records of SRMI’s IP royalty payments in the ORE tool. The 2021 data reveals that SRMI has made the required IP royalty payments. Moreover, several of the Datus listed to receive the 2021 royalty payments are named in the resolution signed by IP leaders from SRMI’s host communities.
The PH-EITI Secretariat is currently in communication with Bantay Kita to clarify the total amount outstanding from SRMI. Further details are also being sought regarding the specific payment arrangement agreed upon between SRMI and the IP communities for these royalty payments. Once these clarifications are obtained, the PH-EITI Secretariat will engage with other relevant agencies to properly address this issue.
Case Number
Issue Concern
Location
Complainant
Date Filed
Status
:
:
:
:
:
:
Devastation of mangrove areas and farmlands in Loreto, Dinagat Islands
Municipality of Loreto, Dinagat Islands
Esperanza Cansim-ong Irrigators Association (Brgy. Esperanza, Loreto, Dinagat Islands)
Campintac Farmers Association (Brgy. Panamaon, Loreto, Dinagat Islands)
November 2023
Per checking in MGB CARAGA's directory, companies with nickel mining operations in Loreto, Dinagat Islands include the following (all of which are reporting to PH-EITI):
Sinosteel Philippines H. Y. Mining Corporation
Century Peak Corporation
SR Metals, Inc. (Operator) | Vista Buena Mining Corporation (Contractor)
AAM-PHIL Natural Resources Exploration and Development Corporation.
The MSG recommends conducting a science-based investigation on the complaint from the Municipality of Loreto to further identify the specific minerals and trace the processing plants that caused the siltation.
Case Number
Issue Concern
Location
Complainant
Date Filed
Status
:
:
:
:
:
:
Assistance in collecting royalties from mining activities and other businesses in Diwalwal, Monkayo, Davao de Oro
Diwalwal, Monkayo, Davao de Oro
Datu Mario A. Buntas
February 2024
The Secretariat received correspondence from NCIP regarding the matter. NCIP’s Ancestral Domains Office referred the matter to Regional Director Atty. Geroncio Aguio of NCIP Region XI. Atty. Aguio reported that their regional office has sent communication letters to the DENR-LMS of Region XI and the LRA-ROD Region XI. Additionally, a letter was dispatched to the NCIP Davao de Oro Provincial Office for verification of the facts concerning Lot 3809. Atty. Aguio assured that their office will continuously cooperate and assist in resolving the issue and will keep us updated on any correspondence received from the contacted agencies.
Case Number
Issue Concern
Location
Complainant
Date Filed
Status
:
:
:
:
:
:
Illegal exploration activities in Buyaan Watershed
Buyaan Watershed, Surigao del Sur
Chito Trillanes
March 2023
The Secretariat forwarded the letter to the DENR’s Action Center email. MGB CARAGA acknowledged receipt of the email on April 4 and stated that they will duly act on the matter accordingly.
Case Number
Issue Concern
Location
Complainant
Date Filed
Status
:
:
:
:
:
:
Alleged unauthorized mining and pre-exploration activities by Yamang Mineral Corporation (YMC) within the ancestral domain of the Logan tribe in Licuan-Baay, Abra, conducted without valid Free, Prior, and Informed Consent (FPIC), involving procedural violations, lack of transparency, continued operations despite a Cease and Desist Order, and potential environmental, cultural, and livelihood impacts on the community.
Licuan-Baay, Province of Abra
(Affecting multiple barangays; part of the Malanas and Baay River watersheds, tributaries of the Abra River)
Community representatives of Licuan-Baay, Abra
Led by Fr. Gary, Parish Priest of Licuan-Baay and representative of the Diocese of Bangued Social Action Center, on behalf of the Logan tribe / Indigenous Cultural Community (ICC)
a. August 12, 2025 – Submission of a collective community resolution opposing exploration activities;
b. Subsequently elevated to the PH-EITI MSG during the presentation of community concerns (2025)
a. Cease and Desist Order issued by NCIP-CAR (November 8, 2024);
b. FPIC application filed by YMC after the CDO;
c. Community opposition formally documented;
d. Matter referred for transparency, coordination, and follow-up with NCIP and DENR;
e. PH-EITI MSG informed and engaged for monitoring and feedback.
Case Number
Issue Concern
Location
Complainant
Date Filed
Status
:
:
:
:
:
:
Alleged large-scale sand extraction and dredging operations in Zambales, misrepresented as desilting or flood control projects, with extracted sand reportedly transported to Manila Bay reclamation projects and the Bulacan International Airport. The operations are linked to environmental degradation, coastal erosion, decline of fisheries (particularly the bangus fry industry), inconsistencies in reported revenues, weak regulatory oversight, and lack of transparency and accountability among involved companies and government agencies.
Province of Zambales, particularly affecting the Santo Tomas, Bukaw, and Maloma river systems
Zambales Ecological Network (ZEN), Represented by Ms. Heidi Fernandez-Boa, Executive Director
Presentation elevated to the PH-EITI Multi-Stakeholder Group (during the 103rd MSG meeting on Dec. 15, 2025)
a. Issue escalated to multiple authorities, including DENR, since 2021;
b. Presidential instruction issued to DENR to investigate and consider repeal of DAO 13, s. 2019, with no publicly disclosed report as of the meeting;
c. Dredging in Maloma River suspended on March 14, 2024 following community protests;
d. Identified operators include Shauffle Resources Incorporated and other contractors;
e. Environmental Compliance Certificates (ECCs) issued, though EIS classification is contested;
f. Legal remedies (e.g., Writ of Kalikasan) under serious consideration by complainants.
Case Number
Issue Concern
Location
Complainant
Date Filed
Status
:
:
:
:
:
:
Alleged sand‑mining disguised as river “dredging/flood‑control” projects in Zambales, resulting in coastal erosion and socio‑economic harm.
Bucao River (Botolan), Maloma River (San Felipe) and Santo Tomas River (San Marcelino/San Narciso/San Felipe), Zambales, Philippines.
Zambales Ecological Network (ZEN) and affected local communities (fishers and resort owners).
Presentation during 103rd PH‑EITI Multi‑Stakeholder Group (MSG) meeting
Complainants asked PH‑EITI to facilitate an independent review and request documentation and convene relevant agencies to investigate the environmental and social impacts of the dredging projects in Zambales
Case Number
Issue Concern
Location
Complainant
Date Filed
Status
:
:
:
:
:
:
Concerns over Yamang Mineral Corporation (YMC) exploration activities in the ancestral domain of the Logan tribe in Licuan‑Baay, Abra.
Licuan‑Baay and neighbouring municipalities (Tubo, Manabo and San Juan), Abra Province, Philippines.
Representatives from the Diocese of Bangued’s Social Action Center and community leaders from the Logan tribe, assisted by Father Gary (Parish Priest of Licuan‑Baay).
NovemberMSG members offered to follow up with senior officials from the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) and National Commission on Indigenous People (NCIP). The group noted that while YMC cited an ATVM, IPRA requires certification preconditions and FPIC before exploration and recommended that government lawyers provide a definitive interpretation. MSG members suggested that the community explore legal remedies such as a Writ of Kalikasan and offered to connect them with legal aid organisations. PH‑EITI committed to monitor the case, share information within the MSG, and incorporate transparency around exploration and reclamation projects into its governance agenda.
This case highlights broader governance issues – the absence of FPIC and certification preconditions before exploration, contradictory interpretations of the law, opaque and inconsistent permitting practices, weak monitoring by regulatory agencies, and potential intimidation and undue influence in the consultation process. Community mobilisation, a pastoral statement from the local diocese and a congressional inquiry demonstrate the growing demand for accountability. As of January 2026, the FPIC process remains contested, heavy equipment has been sighted despite the cease order, and there is still no confirmed approval for YMC’s exploration permit
November
Pending Inquiry
No incoming issues reported.
A government-led, multi-stakeholder initiative implementing EITI, the global standard that promotes the open, accountable management, and good governance of oil, gas, and mineral resources. PH-EITI was created on 26 November 2013 through EO No. 147, s. of 2013. It is a government commitment first announced through EO No. 79, s. of 2012.